What will the court rule in the case of Oscar Pistorius, the Blade Runner, who shot and killed his girlfriend?

Follow |   97
Recruiting
  1. Welcome. First, let us explain the four tasks in each question. This button will later bring you to the wiki with some background information to the question. Now please click the blue arrow > to continue.
  2. This button will show you the exact judgement rule which specifies how the question will be settled and the winner determined. You must accept the rule to unlock trading.
  3. Clicking here will open the trading section where you can then buy and sell predictions using your virtual credits.
  4. The last button will bring you to the market talk section. Try to convince other traders of your predictions with a good argument.
  5. The better your predictions are compared to other traders, the higher will be your share of the incentive.
  1. Welcome! First, please click the “book” icon to jump to a question's information wiki.
  1. Great! Now please click here to check the exact judgement rule.
  1. Now, let’s do your first trade together. Please click here.
  1. Last task: Now convince other traders of your answer to push its price.
  1. When finished, click here to proceed to the next question.
  2. Click here to return to the previous question.
  3. Click here to jump to any question directly.
  4. Continue to trade, talk, or rate before proceeding to the next question.
  • No questions for this search term
  1. This is how the question will be judged in the end, when the final outcome becomes known.
  2. This is the precise date or end of the period to which the question refers.
  3. After reading the judgement rule, please click here.
Close

§ Judgement rule

How will the final result of the question be determined?

Modify Final result
First trial result, before any appeals, after bail hearing. If convicted of multiple charges, the one carrying the highest prison term will be judged as the Final Answer.

Answer options

Widget Price
● Manslaughter
94.10 %
● Other conviction
4.23 %
● Acquitted of all charges
1.65 %

Price trend

Transactions
  1. Study the background information carefully.
  2. Read the background information carefully, before proceeding.

Wiki article

Edit

Blade Runner (Oscar Pistorius) London Olympics 2012

Background

Wikipedia article: Oscar Pistorius

Recent developments

Oscar Pistorious stated that the killing was an accident. [1] His court appearance was postponed from June 4 to August 19, 2013 to allow the prosecutors more time for investigation. [4] The court verdict of the murder trial is entirely up in the air: Prosecutors charge him with premeditated murder and say he killed her intentionally, whereas Pistorius denies murder and says he believed to be reacting in lawful self-defence. [6]

In a short hearing on 19 August 2013, Pistoris was indicted for premedidated murder. The trial is to start on the 3rd of March next year and expected to last until 20th of March 8 [7].

Analysis

  • Evidence -- In the indictment statement after a 6-month investigation, prosecution stated that the most telling evidence stems from cellphone records and projectile trajectories and plans to present 100 witnesses at the trial [7].
  • Media behaviour -- In an Afrikaans newspaper, Jacques Steenkamp reporter wrote that Oskar Pistoius was seen "with a beautiful woman" buying an Audi R8 sports car. [8] Readers may have been misled by the report; the press ombudsman subsequently established the woman was in fact Pistorious' cousin. [9]

Possible verdicts

As of 8 August 2014, the following verdicts are possible [10]:

  • Guilty of premeditated murder (minimum term 25 years)
  • Guilty of murder (up to life)
  • Guilty of manslaughter/culpable homicide (maximum term 15 years)
  • Guilty of other charges -- for discharging firearms in public (maximum 5 years) and/or for illegal possession of ammunition (maimum 15 years)
  • Acquitted

The verdict

In the first partial verdict of 11 September 2014, Judge Thokozile Masipa ruled that the prosecution had not presented sufficient evidence to prove murder or premedidated murder beyond reasonable doubt. [11]

  1. Oscar Pistorius murder charge: key points of athlete's statement - The Telegraph, 21 February 2013
  2. Oscar Pistorius murder charge: What the law has in store - News.com, 21 February 2013
  3. Police took photos of Oscar Pistorius on their phones - USA Today, April 16, 2013
  4. Reuters, June 4, 2013
  5. 'He shot her - that's it': Detective who first led murder case says why he is convinced Blade Runner is guilty - DailyMail, May 1, 2013
  6. Oscar Pistorius to return to public spotlight - The Associated Press, June 3, 2013
  7. Oscar Pistorius Indicted For Murder - Huffington Post, August 19, 2013
  8. Oscar takes ‘beautiful’ young woman to see his racy R1.5m Audi R8 - City Press, 30 June 2013
  9. Papers ordered to apologise to Pistorius - news24, 24 August 2013
  10. Oscar Pistorius: the verdicts the trial judge can reach - The Telegraph, 8 August 2014
  11. Oscar not guilty of murder, says judge - IOL News, 11 September 2014

Topics

Assign
  1. Offering the reason for your trade may convince other traders to follow your opinion.
  2. Click '+' if you agree, or '–' to disagree. You get a credit for every rating you make.
  3. For each '+' the author will get +100 credits added to his trading account .
  4. If you rate a comment with "-", please reply and state your objection.
  5. Now please rate, reply, or write your own comment. Best of luck!

Reasons and arguments Analyze

USD 100
Total prize money
Top 5 participants (Ranking) Credits
1. Carina Weeks 53,952.24
2. John Yeadon 27,745.31
3. Mark Peacock 22,882.88
4. Frank Ohl 22,535.01
5. Anthony Liu 18,417.91
Photo Tessa Plen
Question owner:
Tessa Plen
  • 61,354 Views
  • 106 Messages
  • 538 Transactions
This question has 97 followers