Question
Will Paper 1 (Huang 2014) replicate?
Judgement rule
Primary study outcome: 180 participants from the United States and Hong Kong participated. Participants were presented with a blank map of a fictional city and were randomly assigned to indicate on the map where either a high-SES or low-SES person might live. US participants expected the high-SES person to live further north (M = +0.98, SD = 1.85) than the low-SES person (M = -0.69, SD = 2.19), t(78) = 3.69, p < .001, d = .83, 95% CI [.37, 1.30]. Conversely, HK participants expected the low-SES person to live further north (M = +0.63, SD = 2.75) than the high-SES person (M = -0.92, SD = 2.47), t(98) = - 2.95, p = .004, d = -.59, 95% CI [-.99, -.19]. The authors explained that wealth in Hong Kong is concentrated in the south of the city, and wealth in cities in the United States is more commonly concentrated in the north of the city. As a consequence, cultures differ in their assumptions of wealth concentration in fictional cities.
Two alternatives
until
New question proposed declined on 2019/09/25 10:52:33
This rule gives a summary but instead needs a clear definition of what would by judged to be a replication and by what experiment, specifically.
...more